The "Cheating" Myth: What Science Says About E-Biking for Fitness

The "Cheating" Myth: What Science Says About E-Biking for Fitness

For years, a persistent myth has circulated in the cycling world: that riding an electric bike is "cheating." The logic seems simple—if a motor is helping you, your body isn't doing the work.

However, recent physiological studies and real-world data are proving the skeptics wrong. In fact, research suggests that e-bikes might be the most effective tool for long-term cardiovascular health and sustainable fitness.

Whether you’re a seasoned mountain biker or someone looking to get back into shape, here is the science-backed breakdown of how pedal assist actually transforms your body.

 

1. The Heart Rate Paradox: High Intensity, Lower Perception

The most famous study on this topic, published by Brigham Young University (BYU), monitored experienced mountain bikers as they tackled the same loop on both traditional bikes and e-MTBs.

The Findings: Riders on e-bikes maintained a heart rate equivalent to 94% of the intensity of a manual bike ride.

Why it matters: While the riders were firmly in the "vigorous-intensity" heart rate zone (the sweet spot for cardiovascular strengthening), they reported that the ride felt much easier.

The Takeaway: E-bikes allow you to perform high-intensity exercise without the mental "suffering" that often leads people to quit. You get the workout, but your brain thinks you’re just having fun.

 

2. The "Frequency" Factor: Volume Over Intensity

Fitness isn't just about how hard you work in one session; it's about how often you show up. Data from transportation studies show a fascinating trend: e-bike owners ride more often and significantly farther than traditional cyclists.

The Barrier: On a manual bike, factors like heavy headwinds, a long hill on the way to work, or simply feeling "a bit tired" are enough to make you leave the bike in the garage.

The Solution: Pedal assist removes these psychological barriers. Because you know you have support, you are more likely to choose the bike over the car.

The Math: A 60-minute moderate ride four times a week provides significantly more health benefits than one 20-minute "all-out" struggle once a week.

 

3. Active Recovery and Joint Longevity

One of the greatest benefits of e-biking is that it makes cycling a "lifelong sport."

Low Impact: Like traditional cycling, e-biking is low-impact, making it ideal for those with knee or hip concerns.

Smoothing the Peaks: The motor assists most during "peak load" moments—such as accelerating from a dead stop or pushing through a steep incline. These are the moments that typically put the most strain on joints. By smoothing out these peaks, e-bikes allow for a consistent, fluid motion that builds muscle without risking injury.

Strategic Intensity: Using different assist levels allows you to treat your ride as "Active Recovery." You can keep your legs moving and your blood flowing on days when your body isn't ready for a heavy lift.

 

4. Science of the "Flow State"

The PMC pilot study also noted that e-bike riders often experienced a more consistent "flow state." On a traditional bike, steep technical climbs can force a rider to stop or "redline" their heart rate, causing fatigue and a drop in focus.

With pedal assist, riders can maintain a steady cadence. This steady effort is excellent for Metabolic Conditioning, helping the body become more efficient at burning fat and improving the body’s ability to use oxygen.

 

 

Comparison: Traditional vs. E-Bike Exercise

Metric

Traditional MTB

E-MTB (Pedal Assist)

Avg. Heart Rate

~145 bpm

~136 bpm

Caloric Burn

Very High (per mile)

Moderate-High (per mile)

Ride Duration

Often Shorter

2x - 3x Longer

Psychological Barrier

High (Fear of hills/wind)

Low (Confident in assist)

 

FAQs: E-Biking & Your Health

Q: Can I still lose weight if the motor is doing some work?

A: Yes. Weight loss is a result of consistent caloric deficit and elevated metabolic rate. Because e-bikers tend to stay out for longer durations, the total caloric burn of an e-bike session often equals or exceeds a traditional bike ride.

Q: Is "Throttle only" still exercise?

A: Using only the throttle provides very little physical benefit beyond the core stability required to balance. To see fitness results, we recommend using Pedal Assist Levels 1-3, which require you to engage your glutes, quads, and calves to move.

Q: Is it safe for people with heart conditions?

A: Many doctors actually recommend e-bikes because they allow patients to stay active without "spiking" their heart rate into dangerous territory. However, you should always consult with your physician before starting a new exercise regimen.

 


 

Finding the Right Balance

At VELOWAVE, we design our bikes to be tools for empowerment. Whether you're using the Brawny to conquer hills that once seemed impossible, or the Forest XM to find your flow on the trails, the goal is the same: to keep you moving.

Previous Next

Leave a comment

0 comments

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.